A piece of advice DO NOT base your purchase on someone else’s opinion. Let your ears be the judge because it’s you that will have to live with it.
+1. As the OP can see, there are those here who feel the ARC is a much better choice, and there are those who feel the ML is a much better choice.
In the end, you are paying your own money, you need to choose what sounds best to you, not what sounds best to someone else.
In my post above, I actually had 4 "high end" brand preamps in my home at the same time for a couple months so that I could choose which one I liked best. Along with the ML 38S I had a Krell KRC-HR, BAT VK-51SE, and a Conrad Johnson Premier LS-16 mk II.
In my system, to my tastes, they finished in this order:
1) BAT
2) CJ
3) Krell
4) ML
I am sure that order could be made up in many different orders.
The point is, choose what sounds good to you, not what sounds good to someone else.