From my experience with my collection(I own ~7k classical LPs but have not listened to them all), I like below labels(I really don't care for some of the newer audiophile re-issue lps):
-Most of RCA Living Stereo labels(ones with shaded dogs). Slightly in warm side. Dynagroove versions very unpredictable. I like most of LM(mono) shaded dogs as well.
-Mecury Living Presence(if your analog front end can handle the hot pressing LPs) both stereo and mono.
-Philips(holland pressings), US pressing Philips does not sound as good.
-CBS Mastersound issues, excellent performance and sound.(I love those YoYoMa albums)
-London/Decca/Lyrata/Erato, some sounds little bright
-Denon, great quality, somewhat less dynamic than the others maybe due to PCM recording.
-DGG, some very excellent, some so so(ones pressed in Germany usually sounds good). Blue tulip label ones are excellent.
-EMI Angel, not Angel. EMI Angel LPs sound good but US pressed Angel label sounds dull.....
-Telarc/Teldec/FSM, sounds very similar to Denon.
-MHS, mostly excellent pressing/performance.
-I have some USSR pressed Melodia(spelling?) label LPs which sounds great.
Well, fortunate thing is that there are loads of used classical LPs still available and prices are excellent. I won't pass above labels if price is around $1-$2.
Condition wise, it is very hard to find NM condition RCA Living Stereo or Mecury Living Presence. DGG/MHS/Philips LPs I usually see are in NM condition(maybe due to polylinded inner sleeves in these labels).