Dylan, Blood on the Tracks (his best material & sonics)
Fleetwood Mac, Eponymous, 1975 (ditto)
Pink Floyd, Dark Side (material -- Floyd sonics are consistently fine)
Counting Crows, August and Everything After (abundance)
Neil Young, After The Gold Rush (abundance, emotional range)
Ramsey Lewis Trio, Pot Luck (a heaping platter of magic)
(Criteria: Appeal of material, arrangement/mix, sonics)