These record grooves by the way, they are at right angles to each other
which means each side is 45 degrees to vertical, which means Ralph is
wrong all the vibrational energy is not in the plane of the platter.
When I made this comment I was not referring to vibration of the stylus in the groove. I was referring to vibration from elsewhere- airborne, from the motor, etc.
What we are looking for with respect to the cartridge is that the cartridge body is held in locus so that the cantilever transfers the maximum energy to the coils within. If the cartridge body is able to move in anyway during that process it will be causing a coloration. Its only means of being held in locus is the tonearm. If it is able to move with respect to the arm, its a coloration. Therefore it must be coupled to the arm and the arm in turn must be competent so that it actually does its job.
FWIW I use LPs I recorded myself and also LPs that I mastered myself... I recommend doing the same for anyone who really wants to establish a reference.
I found this, makes my head spin, especially with short term memory issues.
https://forum.audiogon.com/discussions/tonearm-damping-damped-or-not-useless-welcomed
Raul is referring to damping the movement of the arm, rather than the arm tube. These are different topics.
In any case, I gather you do not advocate adding a soft layer under the
tonearm base, or adding a soft layer above any cartridge, correct?
IOW,
these 'soft' treatments can only be an improvement if they are solving a
problem that could/should be otherwise avoided/eliminated, correct?
@elliotbnewcombjr
Exactly!