CD Clubs -Press their own CD's?


I was thinking of joining a CD Club, like BMG or Columbia House, and I read the following quote from Dealdude.com, "The clubs press their own CDs, tack on shipping and handling fees of about $2 per CD, and work out special royalty deals with the labels...".

What is meant by, "The clubs press their own CDs"? Are these inferior to what can be purchased at the store?

http://dealdude.com/cdclubs.html?source=findwhat
brianmgrarcom
That's interesting - I'd never heard that. I buy a lot of music from both, especially BMG, and haven't had any problem with sound quality or durability - they look and sound just like normal CDs. The BMG ones do usually say "manufactured for BMG..." on the cover.

They do tack on a lot for S/H as well as tax - closer to $3 when you add it all up. However, you can usually buy from BMG for $5 a piece, so $8 a CD is what you're paying which is a heck of a deal. BMG has a lot of excellent jazz CDs. They're also great places to get boxed sets if you like that kind of thing - MUCH cheaper if they have it. Their overall selectiion isn't what CDNOW or Tower records has, but you can save a lot of money and fill out a collection there pretty easily. -Kirk

For a very informative take on this, refer to:
http://www.stereophile.com/showarchives.cgi?55
What I know is BMG labeled CDs are much worse in sound quality than same artist/album non-BMG which gives me an idea that they remanufacture CDs with poor bulk quality. Columbia House is OK in that direction since they trade with originally pressed ones. For shipping-handling they do overcharge but there still possible to find a good deal on each of CD that you order from them. For example if you are obligated to buy off 6 CDs at original club price for 3 years of membership, you can buy them on buy 1 get 3 free deals and fulfill your obligation with such offers. At the end it figures that you'll have a bunch of sealed CDs at average price of $6!
Post removed