Reubent, agree generally with your take, except I have a somewhat higher opinion of the Sonys. I’ve had mine for a couple of months and think they opened up over time. Put 50 hours on them and they will have improved.
Still, they are not perfect and have their limitations. There is better, and if one has a budget of $300 new, can find better. But for $170 the Sony’s do more than hold their own. But tastes differ and certainly ymmv!