Esoteric X-01 limitted or Meridian 808?


Both players have been noted as having an "elegant" sound. Both players are listing (used) for about the same $. I listen primarliy on redbook so I don't want to get into the DVD-A vs SACD argument. Has anyone done a direct comparison and favored one over the other? My present player is a Cary 306/200 and I want to make sure that whatever purchase I make will elevate over the Cary.
russellrcncom
I used to own the Cary (I now own the Esoteric) and would caution that the Esoteric sound is much different from that of Cary. If you like the Cary sound you should probably look elsewhere. I previously owned the Cary 303/300 and 306SACD. I have owned the Esoteric X-03SE and now own the P-03/D-05 combo. the Cary's are nice sounding players with incredible bass. To my ears, the Esoteric is much more dynamic and detailed. I am not saying that the Esoteric bass is lacking, but that is not what first strikes you when listening to it. I am constantly amazed at the level of detail the Esoteric is able to retrieve. To me, it is these details that plays a major role in creating a sense of realism and the "being there" experience. Anyway, just my thoughts.
Tbooe
Was the much difference between the esoteric x-03 and the p-03/d-05 combo?
I can only comment on the X-03 versus the P-03/D-03 but it wasn't in the same league, the combo was significantly better than than the X-03, much less the X-01, in every aspect. At the pricepoint though, if you have to have a new player then the X-03 is a good value. However, I would recommend you think about picking up a used Wadia 850/861 and have it modded by Great Northern Sound Co.; the performance of the modded unit should be far superior to a stock X-03.