Etymotics Vs Shure High End Headphones


Has anyone compared these headphones? A local dealer has the $499.00 Shure headphones but not for demo and returnable for store credit only.

I bought the etymotics years ago as the killer high end in ear headphones but never really loved them.

A bit claustrophobically uncomfortable - even with custom earpieces -- and a bit thin in the bass.

I continue to dream of truly portable high end sound for business travel and wonder if the Shure products are worth a look.

Thank you.
cwlondon
Check out the reviews at head-fi.org at this address:

http://www6.head-fi.org/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=19

You'll find quite a number of comparisons among the Shure, Etymotic, Sensphonic, Ulitmate Ears, and others.

Good luck.
CwLondon -

I don't know if you're still looking for info about this, but I was in the same boat as you about 6 months ago.

I first bought the Ety 4S based on Internet reviews and popularity. I HATED them. Least favorite audio purchase I've ever made. I tried every day for 2 weeks straight to like them. Tryed different amps, sources, music. They were uncomfortable, and sounded Oh so bad. Bass was non-existant, thin mids, shrill highs. I tried all sorts of things with ear placment, "getting a seal". Though many disagree with me, I think they are total junk.

I sent them back and bought the Shure 5c. FINALLY, this is what I was looking for. Full midrange, solid bass, highs that don't hurt my ears. Also - much more comfortable to wear than the Etys - You don't need to jam them all the way down your ear canal, just kind of poke them in. I also got the Sensaphonics 2xs on loan to try out. They took the Shures one step higher - a bit more resolution / naturalness of presentation. But for me - they were not worth the price differential. I kept the shures, and have happily been using them ever since.
There is a very interesting paper by Mr linkwitz on earbuds.
Here is the address: http://www.linkwitzlab.com/reference_earphones.htm
Plus the site is excellent as well. I like the Sony's he talks about amd will most likely purchase the Shures, but dont feel rushed as the Sonys are very good especialy for the money.