Without knowing, it may in fact be that "X" sucks is your problem... impossible absent data.
But keeping it simple - you liked amp A, you dislike amp B. What's the question?
Amp synergy is not usually a huge deal unless either the speakers or amp or both are way out on some extreme - which in most cases means flawed.
You will also hear "its break in". Uh, not in extreme. As a professional designer do you know how many new and cold things i hear? Sure they sound better warm. But they don't sound bad cold....unless they are in fact bad.
Why did you buy something without hearing it first? All the pointless bickering here aside, that's what matters - where the eardrums meet the air