My first choice is the amateur reviewers here on audiogon and audio asylum. Take a bow guys!
My second choice would be Roy Gregory from HiFi+. He seems insightful in his reviews.
My third choice would be Paul Bolin. (I like how he compares units directly.)
My very last choices are Art Dudley, his infusion of political nonesense is not appreciated, nor necessary to the review of audio equipment, and also Mikey Fremer, who not only has the same problem as Art, but whose methodology of reviewing is very poor. (Thanks to those two I have saved myself $10 a year, as I no longer subscribe to Stereophile.)