An easy and cheap way to try would be a Counterpoint SA-3000 preamp. Muscial, can be upgraded to sound as good as mostly anything out there, has a phono and very good in stock form. Buy one cheap and take a listen. Easy to resell if not but if you like it then send it to me for the upgrades - capacitors, resistors, volume control, take the transistor out, etc. I have one in now for the upgrades. Easy on tubes also.
Happy Listening.
Happy Listening.