@glm911 First off, congrats on 46 years of musical enjoyment from your system. That's pretty amazing in itself.
You've gotten some very good advice here. "New stuff" sounds great, and bang-for-the buck (or is that sound-for-the-buck?) pegs the needle on the cost/performance meter.
It's impossible to throw objectivity, subjectivity and emotional attachment in a blender and try to predict what's going to make you happy in the future. I'll just throw this out there (if you head isn't spinning enough already):
IF you love the Altecs, you can make them sound better than original. While I have extensive experience in speaker upgrades, @pdreher has hands on experience and owns a pair. Not knowing the internals of the Model 19s, I can only speak iin generic terms. That being said, the crossovers of that era used production quality parts, cabling, connections, etc. Those components (caps in particular) are ready for replacement. IF the Model 19s are like many speakers the crossove boards can be pulled and shipped off for upgrades. IF the budget allows, custom, hand-built crossovers can be built and shipped to you, complete with pigtails ready to put back in place. As a "speaker mod'r" the goal is not to paint a mustache on the Mona Lisa, and try to make the Altecs not sound like the Altecs. The goal is to deliver the performance the original designer would have produced if technology, time and budget were available at the time. They will still sound like Model 19s. Just much more transparent, focused, detailed, and musical. Not quite a polite British loudspeaker, but something smoother that you can play louder, longer with less fatigue.
As for the Pioneers, they are still very desirable (and valuable) pieces. You can get a reliable "fix" if you want to make the journey to the hifi repair shop. Or, like the Altecs, they can sound better than original. (A Spec 1 left our shop sounding much better than it did when it came in).
As some suggested, adding a phono stage would be signifcant sonic upgrade and take up very little shelf space.