Dwcda: I just went back to the beginning of your post. We have wandered a bit from your original posting. First of all, you have assembled what looks to be a fabulous system. Very nice indeed. Congratulations. Putting aside the blind testing for a moment, when it comes to cables its easy to get lost in the weeds. The first rule of cables is that they should not get in the way of the music. That‘s heard a lot on these forums. My rule, if I do not hear an immediate difference, or improvement in a cable or power cord change, I go back a step and try again. I‘ve been involved in blind subjective testing in automotive but it was always done with a jury of four people. Test conditions have to be stable and at a minimal level. Testing was always done either in an open field or a hemianechoic chamber.
I have a question. Having integrated subs into my stereo one time in the past, I struggled with getting the phasing right- or at least how I liked it. I see your sub in the middle rather than placed at a node. It is also forward of the plane of your speakers. Are you able to adjust the phasing of your sub? Ie, does your sub have a phaser adjustment? The sub could also be confusing your listening results with different cables. Did you try listening to different cables with the sub unpowered?