Alex, you are correct they are very different players and there is no disagreement about their styles; very different general styles. However, and this is an example of the depth and complexity of the details that we try and discuss here and how there is a tendency to simply “scratch the surface”. First, if you reread my comments you will note that my comparison to Evans was a speculation or question about whether it was possible that Evans tailored his style to a degree because of who (Garland) he was replacing in the band for the the Jazz Track session. Players can do this. Ask a great piano player to sound like Corea or Hancock or McCoy and it is amazing how well they can do that when they want to. In your recent post you asked about a possible “technical’ reason why Garland seemed to have less sustain in his notes. The use of block chords when soloing, which was the basis for the Garland/Evans question, is another “technical” detail. THAT was the basis of the comparison (and possible influence) of Evans to Garland and is just one aspect of what might constitute “style”. The article I posted does a good job of explaining how Garland’s block chord style influenced, not just Evans, but many players. “Style” is many things; perceived feeling of flow (very subjective unto itself, btw), harmonic approach, tone, rhythmic feel, among many other things. One of the most interesting things in jazz is to look at who the players themselves credit as their main influences. Sometimes it seems (on the surface) to be very surprising and unexpected.
It might be surprising to learn that this player:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6jQ9j1bdkI
Was one of this player’s main influences (by his own admission):
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xr0Tfng9SP0
It might be surprising to learn that this player:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6jQ9j1bdkI
Was one of this player’s main influences (by his own admission):
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xr0Tfng9SP0