My daughter practing snare, bells this aft......

Even better, the Sheffield Labs Track album on direct-to-disk LP. The CD was made from an analog recorder running at the same time as the d-t-d master was being cut on a lathe, straight from Doug Sax's mixing console.

Hard for any speaker system (well, within the reach of most mere mortal incomes) to pull off a truly realistic full band sound.

But for single instruments...

My MBL 121 omnis can be remarkable.  I have recordings of my son playing sax, my other son playing trombone, me playing acoustic guitar.

When I play these recordings at live sound levels, from just outside the room it can sound remarkably like someone in there playing a real instrument.

I fooled a few people that my son was in that room playing saxophone and they were amazed it was a recording.

I think if we are all being honest with ourselves, there is an immediacy and attack and clarity of live that systems just don’t quite capture. 
I think if some audiophiles actually heard some live instruments like this they’d complain that the sound was too bright! (even though it’s real!)

Maybe the providence of horns or panels?