"I didn't audition this pair specifically, but I've heard them in the past and have always wanted a pair.
A big problem is to visit a "real" dealer is at least 2.5hrs away. It makes it hard to audition or borrow equipment.
This is why I mostly rely on reviews and forums."
That's a fairly risky choice on your part. You did say you're on a budget. Either way, its your decision to make. I would ask you 1 question, though. How many hours a day to you think about your system? Most of us spend hundreds of hours just doing research and thinking about all the different options to consider. I can tell you that a lot of audiophiles would kill to have a real dealer only 2.5 hours away. But that's no one's business but your own.
If you can only go by reviews and opinions, here's my thoughts. Don't even think about getting tubes. Especially ARC. I've owned several pairs of Magnepans and components from ARC and both brands can deliver good sound. The problem is Magnepans tend to push amps hard and ARC is known for pushing their tubes hard to get their high power ratings. You can have an ARC tube amp for a long time and never have problems, or it can blow up like my VT-100 did, and pieces flew out of the top of the amp and hit me in the face. And the speakers I had on the amp were not hard to drive.
There are also a few things to consider that I don't believe anyone else has brought up. There's reasons why Magnepan owners opt for powerful solid state amps over tubes. Here's 2 of them. Amps sound different depending on how hard they have to work. An amp can sound great on an easy to drive speaker, but when you push it hard, it can sound terrible. People making amp recommendations are doing so based on their experience, not yours, with your equipment. Also, planar speakers are able to overcome some weaknesses that are sometimes associated with solid state amps. A typical, decent quality solid state amp can sometimes sound lacking on traditional speakers. Adding a tube amp can open up the sound and make everything sound bigger and more lifelike. The drivers on planar speakers are huge, not like smaller, point source sounding speaker drivers. This forces the scale and image size to be much bigger. The speaker is able to do what you would typically rely on the electronics to do.
If you want to use tubes and do it the right way, you can, but it will cost you. Given what you're trying to do on a budget, I would be looking at solid state. Belles is a great choice, US made, excellent build quality and price. Parasound is another great solid state option. Historically, Bryston, but their prices have been going up a lot in recent years. There are plenty of other, as well. If you would consider a class D amp, give The Cable Company a call. They specialize in lending out demo units of everything they sell. Big tube and SS power amps are hard to send out for demos, but they will send you some class D options. They're also very good to deal with. Even though they are a shipping based retailer, they have some of the best customer service you'll ever come across.