Pass XP-17 and Hana ML loading question


Guys anyone here has any experience with the Pass XP-17 settings for Hana ML?

I just switched form Pass XP-15 to 17 and its totally different animal. 

Just to compare them both with the gain set at 66db and loading 333ohm they act completely different, while 15 gets maximum bottom and fantastic detail 17 sounds great at the top and the midrange but bottom needs improvement.  Would anyone run 47K ohm? 

128x128ssg308

@lewm Ok I find it weird at list, I will work with that again, how I have more reasons than ever since I got the Unami Red and I will be comparing it with the ML on the same preamp. Let me know what you think about the ML sound at the 47K load, it seam to me like distortion, overload of bass with the fuzzy bluer in low mis range frequencies I mean around 1KHz. When I drop the load on my ML down to 1KOhm all goes great also all loads 1k and below works great. Gain I have set up at 67db 

I am not suggesting you should continue to beat your head against the wall in order to make the 47K option sound "good" to your ears in your system. Just enjoy what works best for you. But your result does not illustrate a principle (47K sounds bad with Hana ML, for example) that others might use as a guide in their own systems.

@lewm   (47K sounds bad with Hana ML, for example) that is not what I was implying, therefore I am very specific about the preamp I'm using. Problem might be isolated to the specific gear I'm using. Im curious how Unami Red will act with my preamp but I guess I'll find out soon.

 Ok I find it weird at list, I will work with that again, how I have more reasons than ever since I got the Unami Red and I will be comparing it with the ML on the same preamp. Let me know what you think about the ML sound at the 47K load, it seam to me like distortion, overload of bass with the fuzzy bluer in low mis range frequencies I mean around 1KHz. When I drop the load on my ML down to 1KOhm all goes great also all loads 1k and below works great. Gain I have set up at 67db 

@ssg308 When the cartridge generates RFI via the process I previously outlined, it often causes the input of the phono section to make distortion. That distortion is interpreted by the ear as brightness.

If you take any LOMC cartridge and run a square wave through it, you'll see that the square wave is passed by the cartridge perfectly, even at 10KHz. Putting a load across the cartridge (in parallel) has no effect on the squareness of the squarewave. If it were really rolling off the high end in some manner you'd see rounding of the squarewave.

So we know the resistor isn't affecting the cartridge to any great degree. The phono section is another matter as previously outlined. So yes, its very possible the 'Problem might be isolated to the specific gear' you're using.

 

@atmasphere that is my fear that my preamp my tone arm and cartridge all together are problematic, the least I suspect would be Pass but its possible XP17 don't like something in the configuration. I was thinking about secondary turntable, i didn't yet figure out what its gonna be but RP4 or 6 sounds good to me. Do you have any expirience with ML or Red in specific tone arms ? what works the best ?