"God Bless the Child" on Idol?

Most of the remaining singers have some real and marketable talent I think.

I think I read this year they are steering more towards providing the singers the professional constructive guidance and other assistance they need as amateurs at this stage of their career and steering away from the judges and random celebs, like Miley Cyrus as coach last year, having major influence, which was ridiculous.

Last night, each performer rehearsed with professional record producers from Interscope records, I believe, which made more sense at this phase than offering up someone like Peter Noone for example as a "coach".

Still, I think ST and JL in particular can offer up some more constructive criticism than has been on display so far. Maybe they will settle into that role better as they acclimate themselves to the new role. We'll see....

The always have some big music hitters on, the season aint over and hope for the best but dont be shocked when you see Justin Beiber (sp) as guest guidance :)
I can see it now, "she was great" (wink wink, hair toss)

Agree, God Bless child was way overcooked last night
Judges really suck, except Randy IMO. It is embarassing to watch ST and JL comment :" just beautiful", " best i ever heard", blah blah. I can't stop laughing when they make comments. To them everyone is great!
Country song guys is hilarious
The girl with braids screwed up big time but she got personality ( if that counts)
The rocker with high pitch voice was rather nice last night
The girl with long dark hair, (Pia?) was also good
Meanwhile only singer that really stands out i think has potential is Thia.

Casey is perhaps the best overall performer/entertainer but does he have the "it" factor to make it big and not become Taylor Hicks (who I never really got) part II?

Thia has my favorite voice to listen to and excellent poise for 16 years old, but she may be a few years away from having the total package needed to go over well as the AI.

Jacob I think has unique raw talent and potential if harnessed properly by the right people.

Pia is a likable hottie with a great name, definitely can sing till the rafters come loose, and has the "it" factor. Fergie, move on over....

Haley may also have the "it" factor needed to make it big in modern pop music. As you can see, I am always partial to the girls when it comes to these things....

Naima also has the "it" actor to perhaps make it big, but needs some polish.

Scotty has what it takes for a nice career in country music I would say.

James Durbin has potential....

The rest I am less sold on as future stars though they all have talent and can sing.

It was hard to believe Haley was in the bottom, her performance of Blue had more class and control then most others.