Sonic Frontiers Line 3 vs. BAT VK-5i

I've heard that boring comment from several reviewers and can relate to it. I find the Line 3 does tame the aggressive tendencies of the Thiels and possibly the Krell amp. However the music doesn't sound boring to me. It doesn't leap out and grab you by the ears but it sure sounds like live music to me. Its interesting (Stereophile review of the SF 300 watt tube amp) to hear people complain about a component sounding too neutral. Tastes vary and I get excited about a system with a more detailed or envolving sound also, for about a day, then listening fatuge sets in. I can enjoy music on the Line 3 all day and night. I couldn't do that with my old ARC LS2B.

The BAT will sound more like the natural harmonics of music. The SF is to much like the Audio Research SS preamps (Cold & lifeless).

I agree with Darrell,In having tried both,the bat is warmer in character it seems like the line 3 was designed to sound more like solid state.A preamp which i consider musical and very true to the music is the,JOULE ELECTRA LA-200MK3,found used around $2200 to $2600 range.I've had incredible results using it with both solid state and tube pwr amps.GOOD LUCK.