@tommypenngotti, If you have sound in both channels nothing is shorting. Lyra absolutely does not like that arm. They specifically specify "a pivoted arm with rigid bearings or linear tracking arm." That does not include a unipivot for very good reason. They are unstable. You are having more trouble with the Lyra which is a more compliant and more sensitive device than the Hana. It is a great choice just not for that arm and I do not know everybody else's motives, but I do not have one. There are certain aspects to tonearm design that can not be violated. There are plenty of people in the audio business that are not rocket scientists and many have motives that are probably not in sync with yours.
Yes! the Fatboy Gimbal is way better. Go for it!