Speaking in general terms, no high output MC (meaning 2mv or above) is going to compare with an MC in the .5mv or below range. Going to a HOMC would be a sonic downgrade.
You'd be better off doing what Jmcgrogan2 suggested, and/or adding a stepup transformer to give you the gain your phono stage needs.
You'd be better off doing what Jmcgrogan2 suggested, and/or adding a stepup transformer to give you the gain your phono stage needs.