2. misc-audio
  3. 1194498225

Analog vs. digital segment on PBS

The show "Wired Science" on PBS this week has a good segment on analog vs. digital with a relatively quick blind panel test on analog vs. digital. I think they replay the show during the week if you can catch it. Nice to see some of the hobby getting some primetime attention, if PBS can be considered primetime of course! They have a couple recording engineers speaking about the merits of each and a blind listening test between a recording group (whose music they use for the test) and some unbiased recording engineers.
Also some info on frozen brains... either way it's a great show for general technology every week.
jimmy2615
edo_musica
113 posts
 
just in case someone didn't post it by 12:45am PST the analog v digital segment video is at pbs.org
http://www.pbs.org/kcet/wiredscience/video/212-audio_files.html
shadorne's avatar
shadorne
7,491 posts
 
Edo,

Thanks I missed it by ten minutes on TV last night. So I am glad you posted that link.

This was very well done.

=> Analog and Digital can both sound excellent!!!

In this case it seems they were indistinguishable in a short listening test...although they used headphones which increases the chance of hearing a difference)

The Wired Science findings only confirm what we know already (but some people still pretend that Analog is somehow inherently superior - it certainly has nostalgic appeal and may reflect most accurately the way historical music actually sounded when it was first issued).

In fact the main advantages of each format are well presented in the discussion. Glad to see they did not attack either format, as both have their merits.
french_fries
815 posts
 
well then, thank goodness the debate is finally over and done with... (btw, they both can, at times, sound miserable as well).
imho it was predominately more of a "money" issue than anything else.
More to discover