Digital Room Correction: Where in the chain?


I’ve been contemplating the purchase of the McIntosh MEN220. I have a challenging room, and I’ve done my best with equipment placement, furnishings, and room treatments. My listening is 80% digital (streaming and discs), 20% vinyl. My digital chain is Roon/Qobuz, Lumin U2 Mini, Denafrips Pontus II 15th, McIntosh C-53, MC312, B&W702 S3 and REL T/7x. Transport is the MCT500 to the C-53 via din connector.


My hesitation is that the MEN220 requires an analog to digital to analog conversion. It seems like it would be best to apply any and all DSP in the upstream digital before my respectable DAC does the conversion.  Is this midstream ADA negating my digital front end? Is there inherent loss in the extra conversion cycle?  Or am I thinking about this wrong?

mattsca

Use the convolution feature within Roon. I agree, it's best to avoid an additional AD/DA conversion 

Post removed 

I’d been using digital room correction since the mid-90’s. After Denis Doyle setup my first Sigtech, I was sold ever since. I also used two units of Z-System rpd-1 in different systems which help me learn much about digital eq. After 4 Sigtechs and 5 DEQXs, all still in use, I’ve learn a little about DSP room correction.

Best place to employ DSP correction is immediately before my DAC. I found that build-in DACs in Sigtech and DEQX were the weakest link. Another observation I’d learn in my systems were the degradations with Pre-amps. However my limited exposure to high end preamps were a tweaked SF Line 3 and a Boulder. But my personal preference is to go direct DAC to amp in the name of transparency. With the right DAC, I have yet to experience problems with dynamics and drive.

Regarding A to D, I’ll go as far as stating that Paul McGowan once said at 24/96, one can hardly detect a difference and I generally concur. I still have a perfectly good unit of Wadia 17 that I use in my living room system that max at 24/48. Through DEQX, terminator, my Karma’s still sings out beautifully. And as far as digital correction sounds thin, I would recoin it as sounding too accurate. One can always bump up the mids a half dB or anywhere to tailor the sound to your liking.

And finally, DSP is the only way I can integrate multiple subs and time their arrival/phase perfectly with the mains. And the end result is true full range, transparent, holographic, and yet musical recreation of each recordings, and sometimes better.