OK, I got brave enough to carefully pull on the exposed tonearm wire where it connects to the carriage assembly. As you might have thought, the issue was the black plastic DIN piece came out of the tonearm itself instead of unplugging from the carriage.
After examining the cartridge up close, it's apparent that it cracked off of the tonearm. I can only surmise that someone tried to replace the stylus at some point and ended up breaking the cartridge and pulling out some of the wires. Hopefully an easy fix??
After examining the cartridge up close, it's apparent that it cracked off of the tonearm. I can only surmise that someone tried to replace the stylus at some point and ended up breaking the cartridge and pulling out some of the wires. Hopefully an easy fix??