High end Class D amps?

It was the SU-G30. I bought one used for $2500 if I recall. I meant cheap in relation to the other Technics GaNFETs. The Stratos was picked up as a "filler" amp until I get get something better like a Mark Levinson, Esoteric, etc., but they worked so well with the ProAcs that I haven't been in a terrible rush to move on.

I think I stated earlier in this thread that I used to own a pair of Nord Hypex NC500 monoblocks. There was a lot to like about them, and I think they delivered compelling performance for the price, but were not as engaging as I was looking for in the system I had at the time. But they convinced me that class D holds a lot of promise. 

In the past year, I've had a lot of fun building DIY electronics (two pairs of monoblock amps and a preamp so far), so I've decided to try building a class D amp as my next project. I like monoblock amps for a number of reasons, so this project will be another pair of amps. I'm using the Purifi modules, and using a high-current linear power supply (1500VA) for each amp, and leaving room in the chassis to experiment with different input buffers. 

This probably wouldn't be cost effective for a commercial product, but that's what's fun about DIY. 

I'm going to use the Neurochrome buffer to start, but I've already started designing a buffer with a single-ended class A output that I'll try for round two. I've got a few other ideas in the works for other input buffers as well, so I can hear for myself how they affect the sound. 

I hope to be playing music with the Neurochrome buffer by the end of the month. 

jaytor I think I stated earlier in this thread that I used to own a pair of Nord Hypex NC500 monoblocks.
In the past year, I’ve had a lot of fun building DIY electronics (two pairs of monoblock amps and a preamp so far), so I’ve decided to try building a class D amp as my next project. I like monoblock amps for a number of reasons, so this project will be another pair of amps. I’m using the Purifi modules, and using a high-current linear power supply (1500VA) for each amp

Interesting as this is what I have with a monoblock pair of NC500 modules.

Which impressed me and are in the Belcanto Ref 600M’s for class-D driven into a two way with Rahl ribbon, a very easy benign 6ohm load.

So these NC500 module (which btw are the ones in the Belcanto Ref 600M’s) are also in monoblocks but using big linear supplies and fed direct to their balanced input their input via the MSB R2R Discrete’s balanced variable 10ohm output so no need for any input buffer board. These sound even better than the BC Ref 600M’s. On those Rahl based two ways.

On the main system these NC500 mono’s have great bass/mid bass (very low bass is still bettered by my big ME bi-polar linear monoblocks with more weight substance to it) same as this amp but set 30w bias and no Class-A switchablity.
https://ibb.co/QnYhmzL
https://ibb.co/zb8vCgR
Upper bass is the equal of the ME’s as is the lower mids (male voice). And then this is where the bigger difference starts, there seems to be a disconnect in the upper mids and highs from the bass with the NC500’s like they are two different amps doing bass and mid/highs.
I’m putting it down to the switching frequencies output filters phase shift that reaches down to 1khz!!!! as can be seen in the phase shift plot in the graph of Class-D’s https://ibb.co/NC7sC8T which in this case is still -25 degrees at 1.5khz!!! and -75 at 10khz!!!!!!!

And this is why $$$$$ Technics with the GaN based, linear supply, SE-R1 I believe have the answer by increasing the switching frequency 3 x’s to 1.5mhz so then the filter can also be raised by the same amount and hence the phase shift goes up by 3 as well out of the audio band.

Cheers George

From an article on Audiophile Style - interview with Bruno Putzeys. 

@Sagittarius: Class D has achieved very low levels of distortion, but is it possible for class D amplifiers to continue their evolution into something close to a straight wire with gain, i.e. minimal phase shift in the audio band? (A similar question from maty).

 

Bruno: The 1ET400 module has the frequency and phase response of a 2nd order Butterworth filter cornering at 60kHz. If you look at the phase shift of that, it’s very nearly “linear phase” in the audio band. To take some rough numbers, it if you have a circuit that has a 0.2 degree phase shift at 200Hz, 2 degrees at 2kHz and 20 degrees at 20kHz, that’s the same as saying it has “0.001 degree per Hertz” phase shift. That’s another way of saying that the whole signal is simply delayed by 2.8 microseconds. If you plot phase shift on a linear frequency scale that’s immediately obvious because you get a straight line. Of course a simple delay doesn’t change the sound. It’s literally the same as starting your music a few microseconds later.

 

Lars: My dad used to say that if you left a CD in its case without playing it back, it’d just sit there accumulating massive amounts of phase shift as time went by.

 

Bruno: What that matters to sound is how much phase shift differs from a pure delay. Anyone who’s ever done phase measurements on speakers will remember that you have to remove the time-of-flight delay from the data, for instance by marking the leading edge of the impulse response. Otherwise the linear phase shift corresponding to the distance between the speaker and the mic completely clouds the picture. In the case of the 1ET400 module it’s just under 1 degree at 20kHz. There never was a phase shift problem in class D, it’s simply a trick of the light that happens when you plot the phase response on a log scale without removing the fixed delay.

I believe Bruno in that modern class D amps with the output filter in the feedback loop do not have an issue with phase shift in the audio band.  I actually thought the high frequencies on the Nord NC500 amps sounded very good (although being in my early 60s, high frequencies to me are not the same as they were 40 years ago). 

My issue with the Nords on the system I had then was that they lacked body in the upper bass/lower midrange. I tried both the Sonic Imagery and Sparkos discrete op amps in the buffer stage. The Sparkos had a bit more warmth and was closer to the sound profile I was looking for, but gave up too much detail. 

The Bel Canto Ref600M is pretty similar to the Nord in it's design approach, using a SMPS power supply and a custom input buffer. There aren't too many class D amps built with linear power supplies. The LKV Veros (mentioned earlier in this tread) is one of the few that does and has received good reviews, so I'm going to give it a try (partly because I'm comfortable building a linear power supply myself, and I don't want to just drop in a pre-built SMPS supply).

How many class D do I have to listen to? Is there a The class D which disproves the "myth"? Did I just happen to miss the good ones?

Here are some tips. The first thing is avoid amps using switch mode power supplies. The reason for this isn't that SMPSs work, they do and they can be quite low noise. The problem with them is they are cheap to buy off the shelf and expensive to have built custom. Off the shelf units tend to have current limiting protection circuits that cause the amp to suffer a loss of bass impact. So unless you are looking at an enormous amplifier manufacturer, they won't be able to afford to have a supply built custom.


This means that the supply has to be a traditional supply: power transformer, rectifiers and filter caps. The power transformer current and the capacity in the supply can have a profound effect on the performance of the amplifier, since class D amps can go from almost no current draw to really quite a lot at full power. This really means that the supply has to be well filtered, and the power transformer high current, else the power supply will sag at higher power (bass notes).

If the amp is zero feedback look for a filter frequency of 100KHz or higher. This is to reduce phase shift at audio frequencies. If they won't publish details like that, consider looking elsewhere.


If the amp employs feedback, find out how much. If details like that are not published, consider looking elsewhere. The feedback **must** be in excess of 35dB! Any less and the artifacts of the feedback itself will become audible (as they are in traditional amplifiers).


I understand your skepticism! The first class D amps I heard I really thought were a joke. But they have improved over the years, so much that about 5 years ago I personally started to take them seriously, but even then some are terrible (we have a small 30 watt amp we use for testing, but it sounds really boring; I've not looked into it to see why that might be the case, but its pretty obvious to everyone in the shop) and some really work quite well and everything in between.