I had the same problem with my VPI Scout turntable. I tried everything, then bought a KAB rumble filter. It worked like magic and did not subtract any bass from the music. There is a used one here in the classifieds for 99.00. I paid 169.00 plus shipping for mine, new. You insert the filter through the tape loop and when you play records, put the tape monitor to tape or it can be installed between the pre and power amp.
Bob
Bob