2. analog
  3. 132479-3034

Medium Mass or Low Mass Tonearms?

Many manufacturers of the tonearms used in audio today do not disclose effective mass of the arm.  How can you determine what cartridge will work with the arm if you do not know the effective mass of the arm?  Most VPI arms are low mass arms but many people still use medium to lower compliance moving coil cartridges on their arms.  Even the 3d arm on the Prime is a low effective mass arm, lower in mass than the JMW 9.  Wouldn't that increase the likelihood of excessive record wear?  I would imagine you would want to use high compliance moving magnet cartridges on most if not all of their arms.  What is the effective mass of Rega arms, Graham arms, SME arms?  Also on my VPI table for example a benz glider falls into the good resonance area on the resonance calculator but it is a medium compliance cartridge better suited on medium mass arm  Am I ruining my vinyl and not realizing it?
tzh21y
chakster's avatar
chakster
6,144 posts
 
@tzh21y all you need is a Test Record to physically measure the resonance frequency of your tonearm/cartridge combo, you will see when your cartridge/tonearm resonance, you can use this one https://www.needledoctor.com/Hi-Fi-News-Test-Record 

Make sure to find out the compliance of your cartridge @ 10Hz, not at 100Hz like with all Japanese cartridges. If you know the exact compliance of the cartridge @10Hz in CU then you can use this diagram: https://www.ortofon.com/support/support-hifi/resonance-frequency 


bdp24's avatar
bdp24
9,816 posts
 
tzh21y---Don't worry about your LP's; a mismatch between an arm's moving mass and a cartridge's compliance results in, not groove damage, but, as others are pointing to here, a too-high or too-low resonant frequency. What WILL cause groove damage is dirty records (you MUST have a good record cleaner, at least a VPI HW-16.5), stylus wear, and arm bearing friction.
tzh21y OP
1,654 posts
 
I have read that it is the way the cartridge resonates in the groove that causes the damage to the record.
More to discover