Schiit Yggdrasil -- 21 bit?

@almarg 

I'm very appreciative that you would chime in on this thread. I don't want to speak or write on the OPs behalf, but he too should be.

All -

I'll up-the-anti. I'd like to suggest for the moment that you forget entirely about measurements. I don't care if its voodoo. The Yggy sounds spectacular. Please read my last post in the New Yggdrasil - First (and second) Impressions thread.

I would hazard a guess that for several reasons (only 20 bit, R2R and no upsampling), by necessity the filtering in this DAC will be close to Nyquist and therefore quite aggressive or sharp (like Non upsampling CD players). I suspect it is this smoother sound from filtered highs and the fantastic analog section that makes this DAC so musical and desirable to some folks over competing ESS 9018 and 9028 style DACs.

Measurements only validate accuracy or high fidelity capability of a device. The musicality aspects are all in the ear of the beholder.

@shadorne 

You are correct that measurements only validate accuracy or high fidelity capability of a device. The musicality aspects are all in the ear of the beholder.

In my case, there is something else noteworthy.

I already have a "virtual" Benchmark DAC 3. I call it an "Oppo UDP-205". It, has a MEASURABLY BETTER AND MORE ADVANCED DAC chip than the Benchmark.

Some folks might now write back and cry foul; reminding me that the DAC chip itself represents only 20 percent of the story, and that the implementation of said chip, analog stage and grace of God comprises the remaining 80.

I will then write back and point out that because the Oppo uses a Sabre ESS9038 instead of an ESS9028, that my 20 percent should really equate to 30 percent.

And away we go.

@gdhal 
 
The Oppo UDP 205 is indeed outstanding and I expect that it sounds a bit brighter and thinner than the Yggy. It may well outperform the DAC3 as you claim. Perhaps the Oppo UDP 205 will be another Class A or A+ Stereophile recommended player. Per JA above, we can easily surmise why the Yggy is not.

@gdhal 

I'll up-the-anti. I'd like to suggest for the moment that you forget entirely about measurements. I don't care if its voodoo. The Yggy sounds spectacular. Please read my last post in the New Yggdrasil - First (and second) Impressions thread.

With respect, bro -- this thread started as a simple technical question and we have more or less arrived at an answer. Let's try to keep it technical.

FYI -- I have asked the manufacturer AGAIN about the 21-20 bit issue. Let's hope that this time they will answer.

I am very happy that you are satisfied with your Yggy. I don't share you enthusiasm and will never buy anything made by Schiit. But despite our differing shopping preferences, we can still have a reasoned technical debate about the 21 vs 20 bit question -- as long as we stay technical.