To couple, or not to couple, that is the question

Over the years, I have tried multiple types of spikes (including Audiopoints) into the concrete floor beneath my 175 lb main speakers (inc. stands), and also under my two 160 lb subs (inc. stands).  About a year or two ago, I removed the spikes and tried using damped springs beneath the speakers and subs, and I found the springs to be an improvement.  Most recently, I have switched to using Herbie's Giant Fat Gliders both for convenience and stability, and I have not perceived any sonic detriment compared to using the springs.   

After looking at this thread, I put the springs back under my speakers just for fun and found that I actually like the sound of the Herbie's Giant Fat Gliders better, I know...blasphemy, right?   What would Max Townshend say?  Springs, sorbothane, silicone, or Herbie's dBNeutralizer  all provide some type of elastic damping and isolation.  To me, the Herbie's products resulted in slightly fuller sounding body and better bass/dynamics, while the spring supported speakers sounded slightly thinner.  The difference was noticeable but not substantial, and not as apparent as changing from spikes to springs.  Maybe the differences I heard were the result of vibrational feedback or some slight distortion, but to me it doesn't really matter because it sounded better.  FWIW, both the springs and the Herbie's products sat directly on commercial grade carpet over a dense commercial grade foam pad, over a concrete slab on grade.  With either solution, over time the carpet and mat became quite compressed at the contact points.  YMMV

What damped springs?

The theory of more stuff.

Vibration isolation in audio is a subject surrounded in mystery half truths and any number of wild theories. As an engineering exercise, the explanation is quite straight foreword and may be explained by the “Theory of more stuff”.

Take a surface, be it the floor or a table, on which your hi fi component is placed and it is desired to reduce the vibration from the support to the equipment. The way this is done is to put “some stuff” between the equipment and the supporting surface. There are three possible outcomes.

1 The vibration in the equipment is more than the vibration in the support.
This is not possible as if it were; the energy crisis would be solved! More
out than what is put in. Free power forever! Unfortunately, this scenario
contradicts the first and second laws of thermodynamics, so is not
possible.

2 The vibration in the supported equipment will be the same as in the case of no stuff. The chances of this are one in a million because something has been changed… it may be the same, but that is extremely unlikely, therefore, the only possibility is,

3 The vibration will be attenuated, to a greater or lesser degree, and this is the case.

There are many products out there that do in fact attenuate vibration. Be it spikes on glass, wood and slate, aluminium spikes in cups, ball bearings in cups, solid plates separated by compliant sheets, lead, Bluetack, sand, marble, concrete, the list is endless. It is also known that multiple combinations of the above produce better results because there is more stuff. E.g. multiple platforms stacked really high.

The engineering approach is to get the best result in the simplest manner by optimizing the “stuff” and way back about two centuries ago the Victorian engineers came up with the solution…. the spring! The spring may be anything “springy”, from elastic, rubber, coiled steel, straight steel, air-bladders to flexible wooden strips. As long as it has sufficient spring or compliance, when optimised with an appropriate mass, a mechanical low pass filter is realised.

The ideal is to have the resonant frequency as low as is possible, ideally around 2Hz in both the horizontal and vertical planes and with a damping ratio of about 0.16. This will give an attenuation of about 25dB at 10 Hz increasing at 20dB per decade above. This will ensure excellent isolation for the deleterious audio system vibrations which are from 5Hz to 500Hz.

He’s back......... so glad to see millercarbon back!

So as not to totally derail thread, I do not understand the physics, but like the OP my experience is decoupling is preferred.

Let's couple with somebody pretty.