two way or three way speakers

SF, Franco Serblin says the center speaker only complicates things and he prefers the simple two channel speaker. would the same theory apply to two and three way speakers?

I'd agree - unless you can get a center channels woofer and tweeter at exactly the same height as the left and right speakers then you will be better off in phantom and putting more money into L & R speakers (for mostly one or two people watching movies - if you always have a crowd over then you will need a center to help listeners on the extremities of the sweetspot - you can always disable it when you are alone)

I'd second what Shadorne said. If it's not implemented properly, then the more variables you introduce, the greater that something will mess things up. As a matter of practicality though, more speakers may be needed in a room with a lot of people.

If your L and R speakers are set up properly, and you're sitting in the right spot, you don't need a centre speaker. There should be a stereo image of somebody speaking in between the L and R speakers. That's what a stereo does in the first place and why two speakers are used, i.e. to produce a "stereo" image and a soundstage. Otherwise, just use a single speaker in mono.

Also, if you have large full range speakers with deep bass response, you don't need a sub.

By the way, two-way and three-way speakers, as in your thread title, is not the same thing as using two or three speakers.

The number of "ways" in a speaker doesn't really have anything in common with the issue of whether or not to use a center channel.

Both can be complex subjects, with there being exceptions to any general rules of thumb we might come up with. The short answer in either case is, "it depends on the application".

I'd say the ideal center channel speaker is one that's identical to the left and right main speakers, with all three positioned behind an acoustically transparent screen.

As for two way vs. three way, in my opinion there are other factors that are much more important to consider. There are excellent examples of both types, though a particular application may be in general more suited to one type than another.

Duke
dealer/manufacturer