What are the benefits of a SET amp?


Some talk about SET amps as though they are the ultimate. I have never head one. Any comments on this? Thanks in advance.
ray99
The following uses a DHT 300B SET Amp as a point of reference

SET pluses

Has warm and liquid tube sound - No harsh digital edge
Has incredible sense of presence
Very little listener fatigue
Midrange and high end tone are magical
You can change sound by tube swapping

SET Minuses

They generally cost more than other Amps
Very low power - requires higher efficiency speakers
Bottom End (Bass) is not very prevalent.
Tubes can be very expensive and need to be replaced
Tone is probably "colored" somewhat by the tube
Does not measure well (spec-out) compared to traditional Amps

My progression has gone from 20 years of owning "Sand Amps" to Push-pull Tube Amps (Much Better) to DHT SET Amps (Even Better). I currently have 4 SET Amps - A pair of 8 Watt 300B Monoblocks, a 300B Integrated, an Amp that can switch between 300B and 2.5W 2A3 tubes and finally an Amp that can switch between 2A3 and 1.5W 45 tubes.

To me, a DHT SET Amp (300B, 2A3, 45 etc..) is as close to "being in the music" as I have yet found. I attend at least one classical (symphony, chamber or recital) concert a month and SET amps best approximate the feeling of having the performers in the room with you.

However, there are few absolutes in music. The audio qualities I look for and favor may be the opposite with you. I strongly advise going down to your local high-end audio retailer and listening to a good SET amp matched with appropriate speakers. It just may lead you down a different path. There is probably a good reason why so many audiophiles have fallen in love with technology that is 70+ years old.

My, how the SS crowd is getting so aggressive these days. In an attempt to remain impartial(ha!), I will state that there is a group of purist type audiophiles who revere this type of amp for it's purity of midrange character, and are willing to accept some shortcomings in the other areas in order to get this golden midrange. Since the ear is most sensitive to the midrange frequencies, and most of the musical melody fundamentals are in or near the midrange, this makes some sense. In some of these designs, due primarily to the behavior of most output transformers, the high end gets somewhat rolled off and possibly some tubby bass can occur. This is not the case with all SET designs however, and the best ones are very good at controlling the inherent difficulties of the design. They are mostly lower power types, but not necessarily so. The typical SET system will also have high efficiency speakers, maybe single-driver types. Contrary to the above ravings of other posters, the best SET amps have the best midrange quality of any amp type. Few serious people will argue against that point. Most detractors argue that the highs and lows are not handled as well as the mids, so they disqualify the amps as flawed in design. But, since no amp is perfect, if you focus strictly on the flaws, you wouldn't be happy with any amp. Many SET owners, when challenged with this argument by SS proponents, will state that SS amps provide a wide frequency spectrum of flawed grainy sound that doesnt even give good lifelike midrange, so what good are they? The truth lies in the execution of the design of each particular amplifier, and in the tastes and sensitivities of the buyer/listener. As for myself, I have owned and enjoyed SS amps for 25 years, but now have an OTL tube amp and would never go back to SS again. IMO, there is no comparison in sonic quality between them. It won't play as loud as a big SS amp, but for the SPL it will provide, there is no SS amp made that can match it for musical "sweetness". And that is just a simple, natural born fact. The only thing that SS really has in its favor is big, honking power. For delicacy, detail, and naturalness of sound, it is really no contest.IMHO :-)
If you value musicality and emotion SET is the only way to go. They only work well with high efficiency speakers such as most of the Meadowlark line to name one example. These type of speakers also seem to have the the same qualities as SET giving more emotion and musicality than those with low efficiency and more complicated cross overs. If you are more interested in high fi effects stick with SS or push-pull. If you really value music SET with proper speakers cannot be beat.