If you cannot turn one of the outputs down to zero (back toggle flipped toward the rear) then your preamp is not functioning as it should and you need to contact Mick. If the adjustment is on the 300B output and you are trying to use the full 26db gain output on the 6SN7 output with the Belles then even with the Rothwell's you are still getting 16db gain which is to much for that amp. There are plenty of amps on the market that will work with your preamp/speaker combo but if the Cabernet Dual is not operating as advertised then you need to contact Mick or at least reach out to Johnny @jslateiv and see if he has any suggestions.