Bass rant


Does anyone else surmise that the minions weaned on exaggerated THX sound in sticky floored cineplex's, sold on window-shaking subwoofers in their motor vehicles, and subjected to hearing loss in loud stadium concerts - might have trouble understanding what constitutes an accurate bass guitar tone/timbre/volume? I read post after post on this and other forums of those decrying their systems lack of bass. While I grew up listening to a lot of live music in nightclubs and stadiums from Bobby Short at The Carlyle, to Yo Yo Ma and The Silk Road Ensemble, to John Fogerty at The Greek Theater, I believe I can differentiate the realism of an upright bass and one unnaturally amped (acoustic or electric), and yet I cannot understand all the bleeding over of the home theater systems exaggerated bass sound into many dedicated audiophile sound systems. Please educate me.
byegolly
Indeed it is the first thing people look at on a speaker specification - deeper the better no matter how bad it sounds. Good accurate tight bass response with low distortion is like an ultra expensive finely aged french wine - most people would not even appreciate it and nearly all will go for the "Babycham" bass response. So what's new...yawn.
All good points above, and sure 80% of all the msuic is in the midrange, but I am often shocked that many very expensive speakers can't produce all the music on the recordings. I also happen to like extended treble, but without sufficient bass output that doesn't always work out so well. Give me natural extended bass please.
Byegolly - I am with you 100%. I've been to quite a few club rock shows and the mixing (with the bass often being too loud) always left something to be desired. But that is apparently what is desirable since stereo equipment should reproduce the live event. And the plucked cellos/basses in many recordings sound much more vivid than live classical concerts. There is something strange going on in cultural terms with the reproduction of bass.
Different strokes for different folks.If everybody was the same,it would be a pretty boring world.If someone likes something you don't,it doesn't make them wrong or less informed.Folks like what they like and that's all that should matter.Everyone is entitled to their opinion and others should respect that fact.With the thousands of products available on the market today,everyone can find something that suits them.No,I am not a wall shaking basshead but I have no problem with someone who likes it.Just a thought.Enjoy what you like.