Best subwoofer for a Wilson Puppy


I have now a Puppy 6 and am planning to upgrade to the Wilson puppy 7 + a subwoofer or the Wilson Maxx. But since my room is not to big and I can not finance the Maxx 2 yet I am thinking about buying the WP7 + a good subwoofer.

My slection so far:
1. Wilson Watch Dog
2. Velodyne DD18
3. Revel B15

Which subwoofer will be the best. I know the Wilson will fit the best but it is like 16000 US$ whicle the revel is 5000 US$ and the velodyne 4500 US$. The Velodyne sounds like a good buy but will it work with a Wilson speaker. Will it not be to slow for 2 channel.

I do not play movies and am only interested in a subwoofer for music. Which will be the best choise and who has experience with a good sub for a Watt / Puppy.

Peter
sprbggr
I have the Wilson WP 7s and the Watchdog 2. The Watchdog is a perfect match to the WP7. It increases the size of the soundstage and increases the low end. The blend with the WP7 is seemless;it does not muddy up the midrange. The price is $11750.00

Go for the Watchdog!

Steve
I use my Watchdog w. my Maxx II & before witht the WP7. I turn it off from time to time to check if I really need it. It really adds to the foundation of the music. The Watchdog comes up a lot on Audiogon. I run the crossover very low at about 30 HZ. I would almost recommend 2 subs if you can swing it. It needs to be a very fast subwoofer or it won't integrate. Also you need to cross it over very low to make it blend. I myself wonder if a pair of Velodynes or Revels will be better than a single Watchdog.
I would also look at the new Revel Sub 30 which has a significant amount of adjustment technology built in. Also Theil SS subs are incredible and can be purchased with an active crossover that will match your speakers to the sub. Theil is a great sub to blend with other speakers.
I too am running a WatchDog II with my 7's. I got mine on A-gon for $5000 in perfect cond!
I feel the integration with the Wilson sub is seemless. Like the poster above, you have to turn it off to make sure it's actually working!

Regards,
Bruce

Check out the Escalante Uinta. It is $5,500.00 and it is the finest subwoofer for the money on the market. The Uinta was designed by Therry Budge who was the head designer of both Wilson and Talon. The Uinta is incredibily fast and totally seemless. If you are in the NJ area I would welcome you in to hear it. The Uinta is flat to 16hz and it plays really loud.