If you don't want bright, stay away from the Ortofon 2M red.
I had one on my Sony PS-X5 for a couple years, and bit the bullet to buy a Denon DL-110.
It is more than you want to spend, but it sounds amazingly good, and is a really good match for my TT. I believe you would be well served to save up a few more $$$ and spring for one. Of course this is just my opinion, so take it for what it's worth.