Class A or Class D solid-state amplifiers (modern designs)


Hey guys.

 

Class A is supposedly superior. Something to do with a conduction angle of 360 degrees...so the entire signal gets processed in one go without crossover distortion.

But in terms of sound quality (subjective enjoyment) is there a benefit to Class A? Can class D provide the same level of enjoyment?

 

The dealer I’m talking to says that really nice Class A amplifiers are designed for "reference quality" meaning completely true to the real life performance.

 

Let’s compare and contrast. Which one is technically better?

 

In other words, could you have equal technical performance and quality in a Class D amp?

 

- Jack.

jackhifiguy

@atmasphere 

@spenav 

I have heard the amps you mentioned at length.  I knew Tommy O'Brien personally and he came to many of our Audio Raves back in the day.  He is a really nice gentleman and his products are excellent.  That being said, those designs cannot produce the sound of a Class A tube amp we manufacturer.  Again, everyone has what they want from their system.  We offer several options out of many available.  You don't need me to validate your system or any of your choices.  If someone is happy with their system and sound, that is what this is all about, right?

 

So what companies would I say are my competition - for the Class A tube mono-blocks I would say that's a good question.  I havenot heard that many that are point-to-point wired amplifiers using the best parts quality with customer made transformers and chokes, Audio Note non-magnetic resistors, V-Caps, copper plates, etc.  I have heard most of the typical tube amps most of you are familiar with but not many Class A tube amplifiers.  Lamm is a company that I would consider competition.  For the hybrid power amplifiers I would say Aesthetix Audio would be.

We have a fantastic music room in Northern New Jersey.  We are always open to host and have people bring equipment over to hear how things sound.  We are audio people and love to hear new things.

 

I am not trying to bash any manufacturer.  We need many manufacturers in the business to deliver products at various price points.  We modify and upgrade components weekly for people who what to improve the sound of their system.  We are happy to help.

Happy Listening.

  

     

 

I have a Rowland Continuum 500 Class D amp that runs circles around my two Plinius integrateds, one a model 9200 and the other a Hautonga. The Plinius Hautonga is good and I believe a dark horse at its price range, but the Rowland Class D is simply better driving Dynaudio C1 speakers. I recently had to send the Rowland for repair as both channels sounded wrong, one channel was slightly distorted while the other channel sounded muted. As it turned out both Icepower modules were malfunctioning and had to be replaced at a cost over $1,000. The Rowland amp was rarely used over its 10+ years of ownership as I was mostly overseas working so I only got to use it a few times every year whenever I was home. Yet both modules failed. The repair tech told me the inside of the amp was pristine and looked brand new, and everything else was on spec. This makes me think the Class D modules may not be built to the same very high standard as the rest of the amp. Not generalizing just narrating my experience. While I love the Rowland sonics next time I buy an amp it is probably not going to be Class D.

@spenav - much appreciated on the AGD experience - I will probably try and give the Tempo di Gani a listen

 

@twoleftears - appreciate the suggestion

 

Have a great day!

Saying which is better, class A or D is like asking which is better, tubes or solid state. There is no definitive answer. Great and mediocre in all class types. Part personal, part associated equipment, part environment, part 'your' ears also come into play.