Your 40 x 60 room is really large and doesn't have many bass cancellation problems, except for right dab in the middle.
http://amroc.andymel.eu/?l=60&w=40&h=8&ft=true&r60=0.6
Based on this, there is a lot of low frequency room nodes right in the middle. If you feel that you are getting full and good amount of bass, then you are probably okay with one Gotham. Generally it is the very small rooms (like 10 x 17) that have bass cancellation problems.
That being said, having 2 subs will definitely help reduce any bass cancellation further. 3 subs will be better. You could sell your one Gotham and get two or three Fathom F113 subs (same 13" woofer). And place them left/right or even left/center/right.
Or look into SVS PB-16 Ultras if you want really low earth shaking bass. They are cheaper than JL Audio.