Those are wonderful posts guys, but I'm not sure the argument is as impeccable in practice as on the page. I have to wonder if those positions are based more on theory or experience. In my own experience, although maybe some of this extrinsic/intrinsic business does apply (and I would agree that a good bit of it does apply when it comes to speaker cables in particular), I have pretty much found that any power cord's sonic signature migrates between components with the cord to a significant extent. Whether all of those marriages are happy, within a given system context, is of course a different question. (In my own system, I have actually settled on one preferred model of power cord for all applications, but I didn't always operate this way.)
If your take is based on experience, then my own feeling would be that what you're actually responding to is mostly a simple matter of how well (or not) any particular cord's sound complements any particular component's sound (and vice versa) -- rather than believing that, as Al puts it, "it is incorrect to attribute tonal characteristics to a power cord, because those tonal effects will vary from system to system". To me, this represents an extreme conclusion that, while it may be arrived at logically (if imperfectly), simply doesn't correspond to what I've observed.
I think that like anything else, this just boils down to questions of synergy and preference. (A listener's impression of a power cord might change with seating position!) But like yours, that's just my opinion...
If your take is based on experience, then my own feeling would be that what you're actually responding to is mostly a simple matter of how well (or not) any particular cord's sound complements any particular component's sound (and vice versa) -- rather than believing that, as Al puts it, "it is incorrect to attribute tonal characteristics to a power cord, because those tonal effects will vary from system to system". To me, this represents an extreme conclusion that, while it may be arrived at logically (if imperfectly), simply doesn't correspond to what I've observed.
I think that like anything else, this just boils down to questions of synergy and preference. (A listener's impression of a power cord might change with seating position!) But like yours, that's just my opinion...