Hey gang, so few different things are involved here.
1- The Dolby noise reduction professional (Dolby-A) was a monster card of parts and op amps. Dolby was not particularly careful with their designs when it came to noise and distortion. I know because I've taken some of those cards and others apart.
2 - Dolby Surround was awful for movies and music. It was impossible to get an enveloping, natural sound field, as it focused completely on effects and big screens with people seated in sub-optimal locations. On top of that, their processors were noisy and high distortion. I worked with prototype decoders that let you turn this down, and my god, you have never heard 2 channel movies like that.
3 - Dolby Digital eliminated the forced channel pumping of DS but the poor data rate forced high compression.
Post DVD I believe (but I am not a composer/editor) that things have gotten a lot better for music and movie production.
1- The Dolby noise reduction professional (Dolby-A) was a monster card of parts and op amps. Dolby was not particularly careful with their designs when it came to noise and distortion. I know because I've taken some of those cards and others apart.
2 - Dolby Surround was awful for movies and music. It was impossible to get an enveloping, natural sound field, as it focused completely on effects and big screens with people seated in sub-optimal locations. On top of that, their processors were noisy and high distortion. I worked with prototype decoders that let you turn this down, and my god, you have never heard 2 channel movies like that.
3 - Dolby Digital eliminated the forced channel pumping of DS but the poor data rate forced high compression.
Post DVD I believe (but I am not a composer/editor) that things have gotten a lot better for music and movie production.