Thanks for the topic, hifinut51...
I asked and answered your question in the mid-1990's. My vinyl was a long curated, pristine surface, collection. Raised around live music, I've zero tolerance for extraneous noise. The front end was an Allan Perkins improved SOTA Star Sapphire TT w/electronic flywheel (line conditioner) and vacuum. A Fidelity Research FR64-fx was a great dance partner, spinning better Grados. Early dampening using Marigo VTS tuning dots and sandbox/granite under-plinth isolation. Fine tuning an Arcam Alpha 9 cdp (dCS ring dac onboard) finally struck an emotional chord with digital efforts from Red House Records, RR, Proprius and a handful of other labels. HDCD shone through nicely with the Arcam. And again, a Marigo dot treatment, a well matched power cord and careful leveling of the box (don't ask.) My active preamp had a terrific phono stage, a built-in expectation of any great preamp in that day. My actual preamp, still spinning in Germany. Search:
Nova Electro-Acoustics CPA-100A JFET Co... For Sale | Audiogon
Did the Arcam sonics match or improve upon the SOTA rig? No. However, the path was clear that I could not pursue both technologies, financially. I have zero loyalty to the gear, only to the music. Audial memory is faulty at best. That said, my sound now easily exceeds, in all parameters that are meaningful to me, my recollection of that vinyl rig. I recently lost a close friend with "big boy vinyl stuff" nearby, and I clearly would not have been able to keep up with the progress made in both worlds, financially. My posts in AudiogoN cover some of my digital journey, so I won't belabor it.
Oh, my close friend Thurston just is fine having moved to northwest Virginia. He is setting up his big rig in the basement of a raised ranch... 35' x 24' with 2 concrete side walls and rug covered concrete flooring. A big time Lampizator, Luminous Passive Pre w/volume, Dynaudio Heritage Specials and a soon to arrive McIntosh MC75 MKVI. He's having a ball streaming! (sold his vinyl)
Vinyl is fun, tactile, exhausting, frustrating and extremely rewarding. I support you fully, Guys and Gals, wishing you nothing but the best. If ever Powerball...I'm back in with both feet!! Onwards! Pin
More Peace (bold print for old eyes)