Is extremely accurate "VTA" adjustment necessary?


Here's a very interesting article by Geoff Husband of TNT on the importance (or better relative unimportance) of overly accurate VTA adjustment.

Exposing the VTA myth?

A short quote form the article:

Quote - "VTA, or Vertical Tracking Angle is one of those topics that divides opinion...That 'VTA' matters is indisputable, but the purpose of this article is to examine the validity of the claims made for the relative importance of VTA...SRA/VTA matters of course, but in the real world not THAT much, rigidity, simplicity and lateral alignment are all more important"

What are your thought and comments on this issue?
restock
I just set the goddam cartridge to level and forget about it. It sounds fine to me. I've got a collection of approx. 7,000 LPs, and buying more all the time. Life is short and there's too much good music to listen to.

Can I get an "amen brother"?
Will_herrera,
>>> Can I get an "amen brother"? <<<

Sir, yes Sir! And all say AMEN! :-)

This whole REGA white paper rational could actually be seen just the other way round. BECAUSE of what Roy thinks about the subject the REGA tts are as they are?

I do of course figure out the best compromise with each new cart I listen to, followed by some fine tuning. But then after some time --- that's IT.
Amen brother, as life's too short. I rather get anal about other stuff (which in fact I do, e.g. cross-overs and such).
Greetings,
If your records are of different thinkness as mine are, set the TT up for 180 gram records. It will be close enough for most all your records and best for what is being pressed for the most part now. I tried at one time to adjust for different thicknesses and it drove me crazy.
IMHO be less anal and enjoy the music, this is a hobby not a job.
Its with some trepidation that I venture into these troubled waters(sounds almost like S&G!). But what the heck I have only one lifetime and only one neck to loose!!
There are some pretty asute observations and comments in this thread. My comments/observations are based on the Triplanar 7 U2. I have no experience of any other tone arm with a VTA tower.
Two facts are seemingly incontrovertible/indisputable :
1. Raising/lowering the VTA tower clearly influences the sound;
2. Adjusting VTF also has clearly discernible sonic implications.
Last night while listening to a reissue of a Parlophone pressing of the Beatles - Help, there was a bit, actually quite a lot of shrillness in the upper frequencies.It was not just irritating but almost unplayable. I turned the knob on the VTA tower clockwise 3x lowering the tower and wow the shrill bits were gone and the record sounded just right to my ears. Out of curiosity I checked the VTF with
a digital gauge( the kind that retails for USD 139 at some online stores).The VTF setting on the Transfiguration L Orpheus is normally 1.910 gm. The reading after 3 clockwise turns of the VTA tower was 1.956.At this stage my evil mind was getting hyper. Without altering the VTA setting I adjusted the VTF back to the normal 1.910. Guess what, the shrillness and upper frequency sibliance was back.
The Beatles Lp is one of those real thinny ones, 120 gm or so.
I then turned to a 180 gm lp - the new Dylan - Through life with you( sounds like Tom Waits goes to Vaudiville though there are some half decent tracks, IMHO). The VTA setting remained constant, ie with the VTA tower lowered. Despite all the nasal overtones the Dylan album was sounding real good.I then reverted to the original VTA setting by turning the tower settings anti clockwise 3x ie increasing VTA. I began to loose some of the upper frequency detail.Separation between instruments was blurred, in short the music was less enjoyable.I checked the VTF at the new VTA setting and it was about 1.880gm.
This was not a scientific experiment but merely a report on some spontaneous and off the cuff attempts to co-relate different VTA and VTF settings with changes in sound quality.
IOWs with the 120 gm lp a higher VTF was called for and the reverse with the 180 gm Dylan lp.
So whats the point of this long and possibly boring rant : simply and IMHO, with a Triplannar changes in VTA settings are actually mico metric shifts in VTF.To my mind the geometric evidence in the original TNT article is pretty solid.
Sorry to rake up a cliched issue but I guess being anal has some upsides !!
NJoy