Most overrated bands


What are some examples of seriously overrated bands? My candidates are

1. Led Zeppelin
2. Velvet Underground
3. U2
4. Ramones
5. The Who
defiantboomerang
Beck has 5 Grammys. His first two albums (more than 20 years ago) went platinum and double platinum, respectively, some time ago. Not bad for a young punk.

For what it's worth, the only words Dylan spoke to the audience were to thank Beck, and to say "He's going to be around a long time", something along those lines and very close to it. Dylan played five nights in a row at a small theater in L.A., with a different opener each night. I have no doubt Dylan hand-picked those openers, and that his comment was spoken in complete sincerity. In spite of that, the comment elicited widespread, muted laughter, including mine.

I am well aware of the critical and commercial success of Beck, but I for one don't hear it. I'll concede that it may due to a blindness (deafness?!) on my part. There are a lot of very popular entertainers and entertainers I don't care for, or even vehemently dislike (I don't want to use the "h" word ;-). I didn't like Stevie Ray Vaughan or, after a brief romance, Jimi Hendrix. Yet they are revered by most. I love ABBA and enjoy Shania Twain (for what she is, in spite of the fact that an artist I love, Steve Earle, dismissed her as "the highest paid lap dancer in Nashville". Funny!), many of my colleagues don't. Hey, we don't all have to like and even love exactly the same things!

I don't rate performers as over/under-rated. I like them or I don't, after listening to them of course. I do have opinions though.I heard some of the new U2 and they continue to suck. It would not hurt my feelings if I never heard another Beatles song or the Rolling Stones music since Some Girls. 


Well, duh! Dylan picks his opening act. It’s not an accident. Of course he would say something good about Beck. Geez! Of course, Dylan has also said good things about Ricky Nelson, Booby Vee and The Sir Douglas Quintet. 
Uh, yeah, I know, Geoff. That was my point. Hel-loo! I, like Bob, love Ricky Nelson (he is dismissed as a lightweight by R & R historians), Bobby Vee (whom Dylan played with before leaving Minnesota), and Doug Sahm. Beck? Nope, sorry. Mediocre songs, not much of a singer (c’mon, you know it’s true ;-), haphazard accompaniment.