Music Hall CD-25 or original Rega Planet?

I've owned both,like both,but prefer the sound of the original Planet.I find it to be more dynamic and involving.Either way you can't go wrong.

Larry

Marty, if you don't do much digital, you may well prefer the Planet. It has a smooth, relaxed nature that would appeal to someone who definitely tends to vinyl.

That being said, I have owned the Music Hall, and for me, it was the clear choice. In fact, to my ears, it even surpasses the Rega Jupiter. I feel the MMF25 is the best bargain in high end audio today (though I haven't heard the PrimaLuna Prologue 2 yet), and not as far off the best CD players as one might imagine.

A friend of mine sells the Regas, and the thing I could never get past when I was looking to the brand to make a serious jump up in my digital back in the late 90s was their lack of jump. All of the things that endears it to many mostly turned me off. I found them slow, plodding, overly lush, and lacking in life.

When I finally ended up with the Music Hall (after a few tries with some other players), I felt like I had gotten somewhere better than I was before. It equaled most anything I came across under $1500, offering commendable speed, clarity, openness, liquidity, and refinement. Where it falls down against the best players, such as my Granite 657 (Audio Aero Capitole and Electrocompaniet) is in the nth degree of detail, smoothness, and refinement. Again, for those who are seriously sensitive to digititus, the Planet may well make them happier.

Marty,

I have owned the Original Planet and the CD-25 (purchased based on Trelja’s recommendation, Thanks Joe!). Both are nice players and the comparison Joe makes above with regard to the two players is quite accurate. I found the Original Planet to be a bit too smooth (lacking detail and somewhat “muted”) for my taste and liked the CD-25 better. I found that I kept turning up the volume with the Original Planet “looking for the music” as it were.

To give you more options … I also purchased the Cambridge Audio Azur 640C and the Arcam CD-73T and personally liked them both a little better in my system than the CD-25, but each for different reasons. (I do not believe either of these was available when Joe purchased/owned his CD-25. Is that correct Joe?) I liked the CD-73T because it provides very much detail, perhaps too much causing it to be a bit harsh on the high end on all but the best recorded discs … not good for those with digititus. The CD-73T was great for hearing and enjoying the magic of detail, not so great for enjoying the music as a whole unless the recording was very very good. The CD-73T was a bit tipped up and “dry” or analytical sounding without enough overall “warmth” to the sound for my taste (I was using solid state amplification at the time … could be a better match for tubes??). The 640C lacks the detail of the CD-73T but sounds very musical to me … well balanced … not dry like the CD-73T, but not muted like the Original Planet. To my ear (admittedly untrained compared to Joe) I like the 640C better than the CD-25. I can’t articulate it any better than to say that I found myself tapping my toes a bit more with the 640C than with the CD-25.

And yet one more option … If you are looking in a higher price range, I would also look at the Consonance CD-120. It is what I ended up with after purchasing the above mentioned players (plus the Planet 2000, the AH! Njoe Tjoeb, et.al.). For me, the CD-120 reveals the detail of the CD-73T in the mids/highs without harshness, provides great low end without over powering the rest of the range, and takes me deeper into the music that any of the above mentioned players.

I agree with Joe that the CD-25 is a great player for the money. So are the 640C, CD-73T, and the CD-120. One thing that I found from all of the CD player swapping, and Joe will agree as I believe he has said it many times, you have to listen and decide for yourself. All the recommendations in the world mean nothing unless YOU like the sound and how the player mates to your system. My owning these players really helped me determine what I was looking for from my CD front end and helped me appreciate some of the subtleties of system matching.

Enjoy!
-- Bob