A dedicated room is not a room where someone put an audio system...
I think this statement is very wrong. I think it is more imperative, that a listener ( reviewer ) be " familiar " with his / her room, than to have it " dedicated ".
A dedicated room is a room ACOUSTICALLY dedicated and acoustically tuned for a specific system and for some ears...
Then it is impossible to be familiar with a room in the acoustical meaning of the word "familiar" if you dont have tuned this room and explored all his transformative possibilities and impediments by acoustic experiments...
My only discovery in audiophile experience, is not the gear...buying and plugging is easy if we can afford it ...But tuning a room for the system is the way how to learn the room and the system relation ...Acoustic optimization is mandatory... And a dedicated room is the only absolute luxury necessity in audio....
I dont say it is impossible to create a great system in a living room , i say that it is more difficult...
Jay is right and OCD mike is here...
By the way there is NO RELATION in S.Q. between the same gear put in a living room without acoustic optimization and the same gear put in a room specifically tuned for it... NONE.... It is a complete transformation like starting from a caterpillar to a buttterfly...
Guess why most people dont know that?
They put their gear in a non acoustically non dedicated room most of the times and the higher it cost the more they call it an audiophile experience...
In truth the more costly device in audio most of the times must be the room......
Sound is first an acoustic experience and lived event which is used and treated in some perspective by the recording engineer with his own choices and trade-off and this recording event must be conveyed to you and TRANSLATED acoustically in your room...Not reproduced which is impossible but translated...
You dont listen to an amplifier, you listen to the amplifier/speakers/ROOM tuned chain... And the last link is the most important one because it is a link specifically tuned to optimize all the piece of gear ideally for your own specific ears...
Guess why my 500 bucks system dont sound like a 500 bucks one?
You can laugh but i laugh last....