In audio experience, the gear, tape,turntable,or dac are less important and impactful than their embedding in the three working dimensions, which like the three musketeers are four really : electrical, mechanical, acoustical, and psycho-neuro-acoustical...
And neuro-acoustic /acoustic is a peculiar field describing and trying to understand sound experience and music experience, there truth is neither objective nor subjective, it is more an ONGOING CORRELATION experimental process that goes deeper and deeper in the mysteries of music experience and perception...
This is the reason why, comparing analog or digital complementary mathematical tools and opposing them is superficial, compared to the righfully embeddings methods...Is a tape and a dac and a turntable sound different? yes they may sound different for multiple reasons for sure...BUT....
All these discussion about gear are born more from engineering marketing and consumerism more than from neuro-acoustic and acoustic science or from concrete experience...
An audio system, become when playing an individualized unique system because of the complex characteristics of his multidimensional four embeddings...It is no more only a blueprint electronical designed abstract and standard ideal device... it play in some concrete conditions for someone...
No turntable, or dac, or tape, is experienced in the same way ever, by so different conditions and different owners...
The acoustic laws stay the same for sure, but no small acoustic room is the same, add to that all others embeddings specificities and then discussing about advantages of dac, turntables, and tapes, in the absolute or from our own limited experience or with only their measures characteristics is illusory to a great extent...
We hear and interpret acoustic phenomena that are TRANSLATED by the acoustic of our own room and the neuro-acoustic properties of our own head, way more than what come from a tape, a dac, and a turntable, so different they can be...Their differences is dwarved by the 4 embeddings working dimensions ...
People are used to buy gear, not used to experiment with the 4 embeddings dimensions... Thats is the reason behind all these useless discussion about analog or digital differences... Minute one compared to any single one of the 4 embeddings impactful dimensions...Imagine now the impact of the 4 embeddings together compared to a change from a tape to a dac?
It is my experience...
If someone is not wrong, arguing about a dac, or a tape, or a turntable this does not means he is right at the end...
😁😊