Neil Young calls out Tidal



TIDAL is calling their files of my songs Masters. But TIDAL’s MQA files are not my masters. I make my masters - not TIDAL. I made my masters the way I wanted them to sound. If TIDAL referred to their titles as TIDAL MASTERS, I would have no problem, but they don’t. They call them Masters. I had my music removed from that platform. They are not my masters.”.

https://www.realhd-audio.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/210118_NYA.jpg

128x128fuzztone

@mahgister respectfully, just because you want THIS situation to be more than what it is doesn't make it so. I'm not saying you don't have a right to be outraged at all of the things that outrage you, I'm merely saying Neil Young said to Spotify "Take down my stuff if this is OK with you". If I were CEO of Spotify, I would have said "OK". Not because I believe in Joe Rogan but because I believe it isn't Neil Young's place. Young has a right to not be on the platform, honorably so. Spotify has a right to say no thank you, honorably so. This just isnt a big deal.

Here respectfully you lie by omission...

The essential fact is not for Neil Young the right to keep or retire his music...He could have done so in another way...His intention was CENSORING appeal against Rogan free voice and top world scientists opinion ...

the essential fact IS  his PUBLIC claim about misinformation accusation  and his appeal to ban Joe Rogan by setting a public example with his action... It is not a contract freedom right at all here the problem...

I am outraged by the general censorship everywhere...You dont even see it at all... WHY ?

I’m merely saying Neil Young said to Spotify "Take down my stuff if this is OK with you".

 

@mahgister Neil Young has the right to speak his mind as much as Joe Rogan or you or I. I'm unconcerned what either Neil or Joe have to say.

Yes he have the right to do so...

But why calling for censorship instead of only saying his opinion ? this is the matter...

Neil Young is too stupid to debate and critic Rogan and his interviewed scientists?

Why did he never discuss WHY they are allegedly  misinformed?

Why?

Because he is a sleepwalker unable to understand anything...

Freedom to speak dont excuse speaking about censorship of free voices and calling for it sorry...

@mahgister Neil Young has the right to speak his mind as much as Joe Rogan or you or I. I’m unconcerned what either Neil or Joe have to say.

A word of unsolicited advice, if you can't say it in 32 bars, then it ain't worth saying.  Of to put it another way -- "I'd write a shorter letter if I had more time."

Make Audiogon friendly again!