Offer / counter-offer? Audiogon rules

The burden is on the offer. In real estate you list price X, potential offers Y, you counter Z. Potential declines or simply doesn’t sign/respond to the counter offer... back to zero. Negotiation over for that offer “cycle”.

Legally, there can only be one offer on the table. So there is no such thing as "counter-offer" it's I offer, you declined, you offer, etc. This is how offer works, here on the web or in real life, FYI.

The balls still in your court. Your offer declined. To me, it sounds like you both know what you wanted and neither agreed. Back to square 1.

All you guys are entitled to an opinion, but there ought to be a rule for the site that everyone knows in advance or it is not a fair trading platform.  This should not be a questionable area, but a known and published set of rules.  Consider a highway speed sign:  should it say drive at a safe speed or---should it have a fixed limit that everyone understands.

@assetmgrsc

There isn't anything vague here. He received an offer, he declined. Case closed. Simple. What isn't simple is that he now wishes he had accepted the offer.