Pink Floyd reunion

Theo what efforts are these Gilmour made?-this is a statement without substance sure DG can seem like a much more polite individual than Waters in interviews but to the best of my recollection he has never did anything to negotiate Waters back into the band.He has run post-Waters Floyd just as autocratically as Waters did in the later years.
Check the other'Gon Floyd thread there's a direct quote from Gilmour where he calls Waters "a Prick".

Whilst Waters paid the price of imagining Floyd were nothing without him any analysis of the Waters/Gilmour relationship will show there was always underlying problems and at times real antipathy.

I thought that the issue was that Waters didnt like the ego trips Pink Floyd (Gilmour mainly) were going as their fame grew...Waters said many times that he didnt care to play to audiences sitting 150 yards away...the whole kit and kabootle was just getting to be a circus...thats why he had the band playing behind The Wall...

Honestly, there is no remote comparison in the quality of the music that Waters made on his own and in Floyd compared to Gilmour's Floyd ( Gilmour loves the big shows, lasers, and big choruses). Gilmour definitely has the ego going...Gilmours solo LP's just show how little direction he had on his own, and so did his Floyd.

I have to disagree somewhat with Jsujo. While I prefered PF with RW, Gilmour has made some very good solo stuff and Floyd music. Of course, this is only my own opinion and others have the right to disagree.

I saw Floyd twice in the 90's great show if it wasnt for all the puking hippy wannabe's...those little assholes can really ruin what should have been an amazing experience, with all the screaming idiots it was only very good.

Hasnt Gilmour only put out 2 LP's? David Gilmour and About Face...I cant see that stuff as being that good..kinda generic to my ears.