2. music
  3. 1408129738

Porqupine Tree

I discovered this band by accident a couple of years ago while streaming Radio Paradise. I immediately bought the latest lp out at that time which was "Signify". I became a fan and also noticed how good this recording sounded and that the vinyl was of high quality.

Two years later, I've bitten the bullet. ( I say this because PT lps are not inexpensive) I ordered the vast majority of PT and one Steven Wilson on vinyl.

This is sort of a pre-auditioning report. It seems that PT has lps out on a couple of different labels. I have three in home now and the lps on "tonefloat" are the flat vinyl profile. Reminiscent of the later Classic label & UHQU MOFI lps. The other label, kscope, seems to be pretty close to flat. The point is, the vinyl sourced for this band is of high quality. (You vinyl people out there know what I mean) You can just "tell" when you have quality vinyl in your hands.

I was surprised that, upon my search, there was no other thread for this fine band out there. I'm looking forward to many hours of splendid listening.
128x128slaw
slaw's avatar
slaw OP
22,044 posts
 
An Inconvenient Truth... my next lp was "The Incident".

This is a completely different direction from the previous lp. (This is a good thing).

First, I noticed that the sonics were a notch behind "Lightbulb...". The different direction that SW has taken here in comparison to "LS" is not as appealing to my sense of taste. This, however, takes nothing away from the musical genious of SW & PT.

Here's one thing I already know... I could have all of PT output on a constant play mode, and put it on repeat and still never think I'm hearing the same music over & over.

This is a good thing!
bdgregory
1,716 posts
 
I was just getting ready to tell Roxy54 that PT's music is similar to King Crimson.

I'm the not sure I see the similarity (any similarity) between P'Tree and King Crimson and I have most all both have offered; however, the fact that I like both of them a lot may contradiction of my statement.
jetrexpro
506 posts
 
I noticed that both "Deadwing" and "The incident" are a bit behind "In Absentia" in the sonics department. Disappointing since they are such wonderful albums. Another favorite of mine is "Fear of A Blank Planet".
rlwainwright
1,904 posts
 
I have been fortunate to see PT twice in concert and I can attest that they were two of the best concerts I've seen. And I have been to a LOT of concerts.

Their sound guy is among the best in the business. The sound quality he achieved at the State Theater in Falls Church, VA was astonishing. And the State is a very tough room in which to play.

PT's sound is constantly evolving, their earlier albums sound nothing like their latest. Nonetheless, there is a feeling that they really do care about sound quality and that they do whatever they can to further that.

The fact that Steven Wilson was chosen by King Crimson, Yes, ELP, and Jethro Tull to re-mix their albums for surround speaks volumes about the genius that is Steven Wilson.

If you ever get the chance to see them in concert, do NOT fail to do so....

-RW-
rlwainwright
1,904 posts
 
One more thing - PTree did a couple of sessions at the XM studios in Washington, DC. The sound quality of these is exemplary, among the best I've ever heard for live shows.

They also did a live concert that is called "Warszawa" that was done in Warsaw, Poland. Grab any of these if you can, you will surely be pleased...

-RW-
More to discover