Project Classic versus Rega P2

What I don’t like about the Classic is it uses the same puny platter bearing as the Debut models, which definitely lends to audible rumble IME.

Rega is smart in that they focus their build quality on the most important parts, such as the arm and platter bearing. Rega’s entry-level products are simply unparalleled in build quality, at least among new offerings. The only other sub $1K table I’d seriously consider is the new Technics 1200mk7, but it doesn’t come with a cartridge. Between the Classic and a Planar2, I'd choose the latter. But you'd really be better off splurging for the P3 or a used RP-6

All that said, I wouldn’t dive into analog for nostalgia reasons. It might be worth the trouble for some, but as a member of Gen Y, had I to start my audiophile journey over again, I would just invest in a good analog-sounding DAC.

There are services available that specialize in converting old albums to digital files or CDs. They can even perform click/tick-repair to remove all the surface noise. To get such low noise levels in a purely analog playback system costs thousands. That’s why I started with a $300 rig and now have a $5500 rig. It can be a rabbit hole to say the least.

Thanks for your input!  I will check out the Technics  also. I still go back and forth about a record player for that sole purpose. I have no intention of buying the LPs of albums I currently own. Also, I find myself streaming Tidal more and more often.  

@avhomeguy - I’ve owned what I consider an "entry level" Rega Planar II. Bought it in 1981

However, I’ve spent many years replacing various parts to get it to a level of performance I am really happy with. The only parts still "Rega" is the lid and the on/off switch.

But looking at the TT’s available today, I would opt for a Music Hall MMF 3.3 or MMF 5.3.

The MMF 7.3 is very good, It comes with an acrylic platter, which I prefer, and the belt goes around the platter for better speed control, but it’s getting up there in price.

Even the MMF3.3 priced at $699 comes lots of nice features normally found on much higher priced turntables...

• Electronic speed controlled DC motor for superior speed stability, isolated on lower plinth
• Custom carbon fiber tonearm with alloy headshell for superb tracking ability
• Counterweight’s center of gravity is level with the stylus tip is decoupled from the arm and acts as a resonance damper
• High precision stainless steel and bronze main bearing assembly for quiet fluid operation

• Special vibration damping adjustable feet
• Music Hall’s unique dual-plinth design – isolating the electronics and motor from the main bearing and tonearm
  

They also come with a reasonable Ortofon cartridge installed and ready to go.

https://www.audioadvisor.com/prodinfo.asp?number=MHMMF33

Give them a look - they are a great alternative to the Rega offerings.

Good Luck - Steve

@Steve I will. I am not too familair with turntables other than the least vibration the better. The tables at this price point seem to be plug and play which makes me happy.

Thanks!

My co-worker upgraded from Carbon Debut to the MMF3.3 and loves it.